Hardened vs. Soft Shorelines

A natural shoreline at Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve. Photo credit: Melody Ray-Culp, US Fish and Wildlife Service.

A living shoreline in Panama City, Florida

A developed shoreline

Hardened shorelines in South Florida

Natural shorelines, already performing their natural functions without any help from us, should not be replaced with construction projects. Shorelines are naturally dynamic environments, and “do nothing” is the first option to be considered when faced with an eroding shoreline. However, most property owners are seeking solutions to the loss of their property in the face of erosion, so “do-nothing” is not an option. Sea level rise compounds erosion problems by changing the location of the coast line and exposing new areas to erosion.

Living shorelines offer the most environmentally friendly options for doing something. A living shoreline can often cost less than a seawall, and only improves with time. See “Why Choose a Living Shoreline Approach [hyperlink]” for more benefits to stabilizing your property with a living shoreline.

Shoreline hardening, however, interrupts natural shoreline processes, reduces nursery habitat for marine species and foraging habitat for wading birds, degrades water quality, and can actually increase erosion processes. Hardened shorelines include seawalls and bulkheads, which are often the default method of shoreline protection option selected by property owners to “hold-the-line” along the edge of their property. They are detrimental  because they:

•Can increase erosion on adjacent property beyond both ends of the seawall, and can result in scouring along the base.
•Can change the gradual sloping profile of a natural shoreline into a right-angle, creating a bathtub effect — an abrupt transition from deep water to dry land that eliminates the inter-tidal habitat where many marine and estuarine species live.
•Do not provide any filtration of runoff as it flows from the land into the estuary.
•Do not provide fish and wildlife habitat — many animals use the transition area between the water and land to find food, rest, and build nests.
•Are a barrier between diverse animal habitats, blocking migratory pathways for plans and animals.
•Can cost more.

 

Keep Exploring!